A coming-of-age story set in a vanished world: Sally Ashton reviews "All the Pretty Horses"

Posted 4 Jun 2018 by Writing Squad in Writing Squad Reviews

“Because the question for me was always whether that shape we see in our lives was there from the beginning or whether these random events are only called a pattern after the fact. Because otherwise we are nothing.”

All the pretty horsesA coming-of-age story set in a vanished world, with every new read All The Pretty Horses seduces me all over again. It rewards any reader who bears with the confusing initial thirty pages and eventually orientates themselves, riding alongside John Grady Cole and Lacey Rawlins as they set out on horseback, travelling from their hometown in Texas over the border into Mexico. McCarthy’s powers of description, long, achingly evocative sentences and effortlessly realistic dialogue draw you into an open landscape of possibility and adventure as you ride with them into the sunset. Or not quite – neither the illicit romance between John and Alejandra, his boss’s daughter, or the overall story, end particularly well.

"my own travels will never quench the nostalgia that the long-gone world of McCarthy’s Mexico inspires"

I love that this is a story about male loss of innocence, a love story told from sixteen-year-old John’s point of view. It is romanticism at its finest, and along with Jack Kerouac’s On The Road, one of my biggest literary inspirations to start travelling. Sadly, my own travels will never quench the nostalgia that the long-gone world of McCarthy’s Mexico inspires. As the book explores loss of the past, its imagery and landscapes are so vivid that the otherworldly setting almost becomes your own. Almost, but not quiet; dangled in front of you, or rather behind, never to exist again.

In its protagonist, this book also manages to achieve a perfect balance between relatability and exoticism. The admiration I felt for John as a teenager is now also accompanied by sympathy as I read the book as an adult, commiserating in his loss and heartache.

All The Pretty Horses is a beautiful book. Everybody should read it, if only to suspend reality for a moment of unashamed escapism.


Sally Ashton

The reviewer, Sally Ashton, is an avid traveller, living and working abroad for more than ten years. This is something which has helped enormously in both the development of writing and language skills.

Her first novel, Controller, was published in 2014 and her translation of LS6 Mario Crespo’s Spanish novel about Leeds in 2016. Both are published by Liverpool based press Dead Ink Books.

LS6 CrespoSally translates into English from Spanish, French and German. She accepts general linguistic work and has comprehensive experience translating websites, general marketing copy and communication materials. She is experienced in International Development, Hospitality/Travel, Sports, Animal/Equine, Retail Creative and Academic.

In her spare time Sally likes to play sports, read and drink coffee.

North West Libraries

Librarians in the North West have pioneered partnership working to encourage new readers into libraries. Time To Read is a partnership of librarians engaged in reader development activity in public library authorities in the North West Region. 22 public library authorities in the region currently support Time To Read.

Keep up to date

Follow Us

  • flickr
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • twitter

We use cookies to help us provide you with a better service, but do not track anything that can be used to personally identify you.

If you prefer us not to set these cookies, please visit our Cookie Settings page or continue browsing our site to accept them.